If you’re a fan of retro horror like I am, you know that the spooky season isn’t just about the latest scares—there’s something magical about the classics. Whether it’s the grainy VHS tapes, old-school movie posters, or the nostalgia of flipping through a Goosebumps book, retro horror brings a unique kind of charm that’s hard to beat. That’s why I’ve put together this list of some of the coolest retro-horror-themed gifts you can snag right now. From vintage-inspired candles to VHS-style keychains, these items are perfect for adding a little spooky nostalgia to your life or gifting to the horror lover in your life. So, let’s dive into the world of throwback thrills and see what’s lurking in the shadows.
1. Stay Positive Even When It Seems Like Nosferatu is Haunting You Keychain
Okay, I’m obsessed with this keychain for a couple of reasons. First, it’s got Nosferatu—one of the creepiest and most iconic horror characters ever—on a tiny retro-style TV, and it glows in the dark. How cool is that? I love that it’s spooky and quirky at the same time, making it perfect for anyone who loves a bit of humor with their horror.
2. Custom Retro VHS Horror Movies
As a collectible or a gift for your spookiest of friends, this vintage-style horror VHS tape will speak to a horror-loving soul. This retro Trick r’ Treat VHS is one of those items. It’s styled like an old VHS tape, which brings back all those 80s horror vibes we grew up on. The grainy design makes it feel like a lost relic from your favorite slasher flick. I love how this brings back the nostalgia of renting a VHS tape on a Friday night!
3. Camp Crystal Lake Candle
There’s just something about Camp Crystal Lake that instantly makes me think of classic horror marathons and late-night scares. This Friday the 13th candle not only looks amazing with its retro design, but the scent gives off cozy vibes with just a hint of something… darker. I’m a sucker for candles, and having one that ties into my love for horror makes it a must-have for setting the scene on movie night. Light this up, and it’s almost like you can hear the distant whispers of Jason Voorhees. Perfect for fans of horror who like a little coziness with their spooky vibes.
4. Goosebumps Sparkling Keychain
If you’re anything like me, Goosebumps books were a huge part of your childhood – check out the new Goosebumps show if you’re looking to re-up that obsession. This keychain brings back all those spooky feels with its classic cover art—whether it’s The Haunted Mask or Night of the Living Dummy. I love the fact that it’s double-sided and has that glittery sparkle, because why not add some flair to your horror? Carrying this around is like having a mini slice of 90s horror nostalgia everywhere you go. Plus, it’s a great conversation starter for anyone who also grew up devouring R.L. Stine books.
If you love these retro horror vibes, why stop with just gifts? I recently put together a list of modern horror movies that nail that old-school aesthetic we all love. From neon-soaked 80s slashers to grainy, VHS-style thrillers, these films are perfect for fans of vintage horror with a modern twist. Check out the full list here and get ready to dive into some seriously stylish scares!
5. Scream Hollywood Video Horror Keychain
I’ll admit it—there’s something about the old-school Scream movies that will forever hold a special place in my heart. This keychain is a retro love letter to Hollywood Video (remember renting horror movies for the weekend?) and the Scream franchise. You could even get a few of these and start a collection that instantly transports you to the days of picking up a VHS tape and knowing you were in for a night of scares. If you’re a fan of 90s horror or just love a good throwback to the days of video rentals, this one’s a keeper.
6. Halloween Horror VHS Phone Case
These phone cases look like they came straight from the 80s. The aesthetic here is pure retro horror, with an old VHS cassette design featuring classic horror movies on the front.
7. Classic Horror Movies 2025 Calendar
When it comes to horror, I like to keep the spooky vibes going year-round. If that’s also you, check out the SpookyAtHeart Pinterest board “Spooky All Year”.
This Classic Horror Movies calendar is a must-have for planning your days while also staring at iconic horror movie posters each month. It’s packed with legendary films like Dracula, Frankenstein, and The Shining, each page more epic than the last. It’s like decorating your wall with horror history. Plus, it’s a great way to inspire your next horror movie binge.
8. My Best Friend’s Exorcism by Grady Hendrix
If you haven’t read My Best Friend’s Exorcism, what are you even doing? This book is a perfect blend of 80s nostalgia, horror, and humor that just gets everything right. The cover alone looks like it belongs on an old VHS tape. I mean really, the cover art is genuinely done so well it had to have a place on this list. It captures the intensity of teenage friendships and layers it with a good dose of supernatural horror. It’s a total page-turner, and if you’re into 80s throwbacks and a little possession with your friendship drama, this is a must-read.
9. The Horror Movie by Paul Tremblay
Paul Tremblay is an absolute master of modern horror, and The Horror Movie is no exception. What I love about this book is how it captures the tension and dread that builds up like the best slow-burn horror movies. It’s one of those reads where you feel like you’re watching an old horror flick play out in your mind. If you’re into horror novels that are as cinematic as they are terrifying, this one’s for you.
10. Steven Rhodes Retro Horror Art
If you’re into retro horror with a bit of humor thrown in, Steve Rhodes’ art is something you need to check out. His designs put a playful twist on classic horror aesthetics, blending that vintage, old-school style with a dash of dark humor. It’s the perfect way to add a little spooky fun to your everyday life. Whether you’re a horror fanatic or just love quirky, retro-inspired designs, Steve Rhodes’ art is the kind of statement piece that’ll make any horror lover smile.
There’s just something special about retro horror—it brings back memories of late-night movie marathons, video rental stores, and the thrill of your first scary story. Whether you’re picking up a Camp Crystal Lake candle to set the mood for your next horror binge or carrying around a sparkling Goosebumps keychain for a hit of 90s nostalgia, these gifts are a fun way to keep the spooky vibes going all year long. So, go ahead, treat yourself (or a fellow horror fan), and keep the retro horror spirit alive.
Stay spooky!